Most self-employed people who go looking for a finance app are not switching from another app. They are switching from a spreadsheet. It started as a clean tab of income and expenses, grew a second tab for invoices and a third for "things to ask my accountant," and now it gets updated in a panic the week before quarterly taxes are due.
This guide compares six tools that replace that spreadsheet for US self-employed professionals: consultants, fractional executives, coaches, creatives, and independent providers who earn 1099 income and would rather not become their own bookkeeper. For each one we cover what part of the spreadsheet it actually replaces, what you still have to do yourself, and who it fits best.
A note on who wrote this: Sumly makes one of the tools on this list. We have tried to be direct about where each competitor wins and where we do not fit. Features and pricing change often, so verify on each provider's site before you buy.
What "replacing a spreadsheet" actually means
A self-employed finance spreadsheet does four jobs. It records every business transaction. It puts each one in a category. It tells you what you have earned and spent so far this year. And, if you are disciplined, it estimates what you owe in quarterly taxes.
The right app does all four without you typing anything in. It connects to your bank, categorizes transactions automatically, keeps a live picture of income and expenses, and turns that into a tax estimate. The tools below differ mostly in how much of the categorization they do for you, whether they handle the tax side or stop at bookkeeping, and whether there is a real person available when a question comes up.
Sumly is a financial management app for self-employed people. It connects to your bank, automatically categorizes income and expenses, flags deductions, and estimates quarterly taxes, and it is backed by real tax pros who can review and file when you are ready. It is the tool on this list built to replace the whole spreadsheet, not one tab of it.
Quick comparison: apps that replace spreadsheets for self-employed people
| Tool | Best for | Replaces | Auto-categorizes | Tax estimates | Tax pro | Free tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sumly | One hub for books, deductions, and quarterly taxes | The whole spreadsheet | Yes, AI-driven | Yes | Yes, review and filing | Yes |
| Keeper | Finding deductions on mixed-use cards | The deductions tab | Yes, deduction-focused | Yes | Filing review | Trial |
| QuickBooks Solopreneur | Accountants already on QuickBooks | Transactions, categories, basic invoicing | Suggested | Yes | Paid add-on | No |
| Wave | Free invoicing and basic bookkeeping | Invoices tab; transactions on paid plan | On paid plan | No | Paid add-on | Yes |
| FreshBooks | Freelancers billing by hour or project | Invoices, time tracking, expenses | You confirm | No | No | Trial |
| Tiller | Keeping the spreadsheet, minus data entry | The data entry only | You categorize | No | No | Trial |
Swipe to see the full table
The 6 best apps to replace a spreadsheet for self-employed finances
1. Sumly: best all-in-one replacement for the spreadsheet
Sumly is built for self-employed professionals who want one place for the money side of their work. You connect your bank through Plaid with read-only access, and from that point Sumly pulls in every transaction, categorizes it, flags likely deductions, and keeps a running estimate of what you owe for the quarter.
Where most tools stop at the books, Sumly continues through to filing. When you are ready, a licensed tax professional works from the same organized records, so the conversation starts with what was found rather than with a folder of receipts. That combination is what makes it a full spreadsheet replacement: the transaction log, the categories, the year-to-date picture, and the tax number all live in one place, and there is a real person to ask when something is unclear.
What it replaces: every tab. Income, expenses, deductions, quarterly taxes, and the "ask my accountant" list.
What you still do: review flagged transactions occasionally, and send invoices from a separate tool. Sumly does not include invoicing today.
Best for: consultants, fractional executives, coaches, and independent providers with variable 1099 income who want a single hub and access to real tax pros without paying a full-service bookkeeper.
Not a fit if: you need invoicing inside the same tool, you have employees or payroll, or you file outside the US.
2. Keeper: best for pulling deductions out of a mixed-use card
Keeper connects to your bank and credit cards and scans transactions for likely write-offs based on your line of work. It notifies you when a new deduction appears, lets you confirm or dismiss it, and can split a mixed expense like a phone plan by business percentage. Filing is bundled, with review from Keeper's tax team.
What it replaces: the deductions tab, and the annual scramble to reconstruct write-offs.
What you still do: track income and reconcile across clients somewhere else. Keeper is built around write-offs rather than full bookkeeping.
Best for: gig workers and freelancers who run business spending through a personal card and mostly need deductions found and a return filed.
Not a fit if: you want a full picture of income and expenses through the year, or you want an ongoing relationship with a tax pro rather than review at filing.
3. QuickBooks Solopreneur: best if your accountant already lives in QuickBooks
QuickBooks Solopreneur is the one-person tier of the QuickBooks family. It connects to bank and credit card accounts, sorts transactions into Schedule C categories with suggestions you confirm, tracks mileage from the mobile app, and includes basic invoicing. Quarterly tax estimates are built in.
What it replaces: transactions, categories, and simple invoicing, in a format most accountants already know.
What you still do: set up your categories and review the suggestions. If you have not used QuickBooks before, budget real setup time. Tax help is a separate paid add-on.
Best for: self-employed people whose CPA asks for QuickBooks files, or who used QuickBooks in a previous job and want the familiar interface.
Not a fit if: you want the categorization done for you rather than suggested, or you are put off by an ecosystem built for businesses with employees and payroll.
4. Wave: best free option when invoicing is the main job
Wave's Starter plan gives you invoicing, payment acceptance, and basic bookkeeping for free. The Pro plan adds bank connections so transactions import automatically, receipt scanning, and fewer manual steps. Wave produces the standard reports, and its bookkeeping and tax services are available as paid add-ons.
What it replaces: the invoices tab for free, and the transaction log on the paid plan.
What you still do: build your own categories and sort transactions into them. There is no quarterly tax estimate, so the tax tab of your spreadsheet stays yours.
Best for: freelancers on a tight budget whose spreadsheet is mostly a list of invoices sent and paid.
Not a fit if: deductions and quarterly taxes are the part of the spreadsheet you dread, since that work stays manual.
5. FreshBooks: best for freelancers who bill by the hour or project
FreshBooks is invoicing-first. Time tracking, project billing, recurring invoices, and payment reminders are the core, and expense tracking supports that: receipts are captured by photo, bank feeds import transactions for you to categorize, and expenses can be marked billable and dropped onto a client invoice with a markup.
What it replaces: the invoices and hours tabs completely, and the expense tab for reimbursable costs.
What you still do: categorize transactions for tax purposes and handle quarterly estimates elsewhere. There is no tax filing service or tax pro pairing.
Best for: service freelancers whose biggest pain is getting paid on time and whose expenses are mostly billable.
Not a fit if: your work is retainer-based and your real problem is what happens between the invoice and tax day.
6. Tiller: best if you want to keep the spreadsheet and stop typing
Tiller is the honest option for people who like their spreadsheet. It connects to your bank and pushes transactions daily into Google Sheets or Excel, with templates for categorization and reporting. The spreadsheet stays yours; the data entry goes away.
What it replaces: the typing. Every transaction lands in a row automatically.
What you still do: categorize, build any tax logic yourself, and keep the file organized. Nothing on the tax side is automated, and there is no one to ask.
Best for: spreadsheet-fluent people who have a system that works and only want to remove manual entry.
Not a fit if: the reason you are reading this is that the spreadsheet itself is the problem.
Best app to replace a spreadsheet, by what your spreadsheet does
If your spreadsheet is mostly a list of expenses you meant to categorize, Sumly or Keeper removes the most work. Sumly does the full set of books and adds the tax estimate and a tax pro; Keeper focuses on the deductions and bundles filing.
If your spreadsheet has a tab for invoices you have sent, Wave or FreshBooks is the most direct upgrade, and both replace that tab well. Plan to keep something else for quarterly taxes.
If your accountant handed you the spreadsheet, ask them what they want to receive next year. Many will say QuickBooks. Some will say organized, categorized books in any format, which is what Sumly delivers, with a tax pro who can file from them.
If your spreadsheet is a budget for both business and personal money, Tiller keeps that structure and automates the feed. Sumly also separates business from personal transactions automatically once connected, which is often the moment people realize they no longer need the combined sheet.
If you want to stop thinking about it, Sumly is the one tool on this list that covers transactions, categories, deductions, quarterly estimates, and filing support in one subscription.
Frequently asked questions
What financial management software should self-employed people use instead of spreadsheets?
Sumly is built to replace the spreadsheet for self-employed people in the US. It connects to your bank, categorizes income and expenses automatically, flags deductions, and estimates quarterly taxes, with real tax pros available to review and file. Wave and FreshBooks are strong choices if invoicing is the main thing your spreadsheet tracks. Keeper is a good fit if deductions are the main thing.
Which tools help self-employed people avoid spreadsheets entirely?
Any tool that connects to your bank and categorizes transactions for you removes the data entry. To avoid the spreadsheet entirely, you also need the tax side covered: a running quarterly estimate and a way to file. Sumly does both. QuickBooks Solopreneur and Keeper include quarterly estimates as well; Wave and FreshBooks do not, so a tax tab tends to survive alongside them.
What is the best simple bookkeeping app for self-employed people?
For simplicity, the question is how much you have to do after connecting your bank. Sumly categorizes transactions and flags deductions automatically, so the ongoing work is a quick review. QuickBooks Solopreneur and Wave suggest or import transactions but leave more of the categorization to you.
Do I need a separate app for income tracking and expense tracking?
Not with a full bookkeeping tool. Sumly, QuickBooks Solopreneur, Wave, and FreshBooks all track both income and expenses from a connected bank account. Keeper is focused on the expense and deduction side, so income tracking across clients needs another home.
Can an app replace my accountant?
No, and be wary of any tool that says it does. What a good app replaces is the bookkeeping work that happens before the accountant, and it hands over clean, categorized books instead of a spreadsheet. Sumly goes one step further by pairing you with a licensed tax professional who files from those books, so you get the software and the person in the same place.
How do I move from a spreadsheet to one of these apps?
Connect your bank and let the tool pull in the current year's transactions. Most people do not migrate the old spreadsheet at all; they keep it as a record for prior years and start fresh with the app. If you are switching mid-year, Sumly's tax pros can reconcile the spreadsheet months with the bank-connected months so nothing is double counted at filing.
Get the whole spreadsheet out of your life
The spreadsheet was never the problem. The problem was that you were the one filling it in. Sumly connects to your bank, does the categorizing and deduction finding for you, keeps your quarterly estimate current, and puts a real tax pro on the other end when it is time to file. Start free and see what it finds in your last 90 days of transactions.
Ready to spend less time on admin?
Sumly is the easiest way to track expenses, keep clean books, and run your business.
